This information is for summary offenses and misdemeanor charges only.

Back to Criminal Defense

Preliminary Hearing

At the preliminary hearing, the Commonwealth must establish a prima facie case — showing that a crime was probably committed and that you probably committed it. This is your first major opportunity to challenge the prosecution's evidence.

The Prima Facie Standard

Under Pa.R.Crim.P. 542, the Commonwealth must show it is more likely than not that a crime occurred and you committed it. This is a lower standard than "beyond a reasonable doubt" required at trial.

Per Commonwealth v. Ricker, 120 A.3d 349 (Pa. Super. 2015), hearsay evidence alone may be sufficient at a preliminary hearing — controversial but currently good law in Pennsylvania.

Your Rights at the Preliminary Hearing

Right to be represented by counsel

Right to cross-examine all Commonwealth witnesses

Right to present evidence and witnesses in your defense

Right to make legal arguments

Right to challenge the sufficiency of evidence

Right to request a continuance for good cause

Cross-Examination Preparation

DUI — Key Cross-Examination Areas

Calibration records for breathalyzer
Observation period compliance
Field sobriety test administration errors
Chain of custody for blood/breath samples
Probable cause for initial traffic stop

Simple Assault — Key Cross-Examination Areas

Identification certainty
Self-defense indicators
Severity of injuries
Witness credibility and bias
Prior relationship and context

Retail Theft — Key Cross-Examination Areas

Surveillance footage quality
Positive identification method
Evidence of intent to permanently deprive
Actual value of merchandise
Recovery of items

Disorderly Conduct — Key Cross-Examination Areas

Public vs. private location
Specific conduct alleged
First Amendment considerations
Officer's subjective interpretation
Presence of actual alarm or disturbance